As some of you might know, receipt nazis are one of my biggest pet peeves. For those of you not familiar with receipt nazis, let me offer a definition:
Receipt Nazi: Noun. The goon who demands to inspect your receipt as you leave a store.
Most people don't know their rights. Most people don't know the law. Here's the deal, specific to Delaware, but widely applicable all over the nation:
It is acceptable for a store to ask to see your receipt. It's also acceptable for a random stranger to ask you for money. Both are acceptable, provided the process is totally voluntary. It's your choice. You choose if you want to humor the store's policy. Just because a policy is printed on a piece of cardboard, it doesn't mean that it has the force of law. I usually just say "No, thank you." and continue walking.
Most people don't know that they can simply refuse, and be on their way. Often times, a receipt nazi will attempt intimidation. I've had situations myself where I was told that "you're not leaving until I see your receipt". Regardless of what anyone's manager has told them, this is completely unenforceable. In my situation, I simply told the fellow "Call the police, if you saw me steal something. If not, get out of my way, or I'll be the one calling them." In my case, the goon backed down. I'm one of the few people who actually reads the state laws, so I know my rights. Sadly, most people allow these abuses.
However, this post isn't about my case. It's about a fellow named Michael Righi. Michael had a similar encounter to mine, but his encounter ended in a much less favorable way. Oddly enough, both of our encounters happened at a Circuit City.
Michael has posted a complete writeup on his website. You can read the whole story here.
Here's my short version:
- Michael was stopped, and was requested to produce his receipt.
- Michael refuses to produce his receipt, which he was completely within his rights to do.
- Store employees prevent Michael from leaving, by blocking his path.
- Michael summons the police, as he is being illegally detained.
- The police officer (Ernie Arroyo) determines that Michael has not stolen anything.
- The police officer demands Micheal's identification (the actual driver's license card).
- Michael refuses, as he is not required to provide his driver's license, as he wasn't driving.
- The police officer arrests Michael, and charges him with "Obstructing Official Business" (Ohio Law)
I've done the research, as this happens to be one of my interests. Here's my analysis on the incident:
- Michael stood up for his rights.
- Michael violated no laws. He acted in a respectful manner, and did not escalate any of the situations.
- The Circuit City employees were quite incorrect in their assumptions about the law.
- The police officer was clearly on a power-trip, and wanted to charge Micheal with something.
- These abuses shouldn't be tolerated. Michael is a patriot, and he defended his rights. Most people take their rights for granted, and don't stand up for them. Michael should be commended.
- Hopefully, Michael will be quickly vindicated in court. The officer should be fired.
- Hopefully the resulting civil lawsuit will end this obnoxious policy at all retailers. Hopefully Circuit City will be spanked soundly enough to teach the whole industry a lesson.
I've already contacted Michael. I've offered to travel to Ohio, to observe the trial, and ensure he received equitable treatment. I haven't gotten a response yet, but that's not surprising. I'm sure he's swimming in correspondence at the moment. I wished him the best, and offered any help that I can provide.
Officer Arroyo: You are clearly incompetent and malicious. I hope you become an example to all the police who abuse their position.
Update, 09/06/2007:
I've gotten a reply from Michael Righi himself. He's pretty busy at the moment, so I'm pretty impressed that he made the time for me. With his permission, I'm reposting his reply...
Benji,
Thanks for contacting me, and thanks for the well worded post on your blog. I wish that everybody's messages to me were as supportive as ours. :-)
It's a shame that more people don't know or stand up for their rights as you have done before. I commend you for not so easily giving in.
I'm committed to seeing this issue resolved justly, and once my attorney advises me that it's okay to speak I'll be providing more updates on my web site.
Take care,
Michael